I have done it. I no longer identify as religious. I have given up.
It was more of a slow fade than an abrupt retreat. Having grown up in a church and being immersed in the culture is a lot like putting vegetables in any type of soup; the longer they sit in the broth the more of the flavors they take on, and no matter how long I've been away from the actual building there is no denying that I was marinated by it. Religion has become stale to me. The lightest flavors are the first ones to go when you overcook the broth, the robust base the taste that still lingers, and likewise I disbelieved some things right away but held on to others as long as I could.
I never believed that I was somehow of less worth because of the sex I was born with. Sure, when I went to a private Christian school and we started studying the 1950's in history class and I would (loudly) object to the lovely examples of domestic life the textbook gave us, I was bothered by the groans that happened when I put my hand up; "here she goes." One person said from the back of the room. I only spent about a year being a high school feminist before I realized there was a lot less pushback when I tried to encompass what the church says a good woman is, and so I associated being culturally feminine and quiet with being a good woman (never mind my horrible personality at the time.). In the back of my mind, however, the seed was still planted that I could do anything I wanted to do and be anything I wanted to be, even as I sat in the guidance counselor's office and she told me that going to college for nursing was a great choice because they have access to flexible schedules that make it easier to raise children, or we had to participate in school-wide, girls-only modesty meetings to make sure we were making it easier for straight boys not to sin.
The seed was still there, and it whispered to me.
Letting go of the crushing box religion has put women in was easy for me. I embraced feminism and started looking at religion's (read: Christianity) hot button issues with a critical eye as opposed to someone desperately trying to explain them away to outsiders. It couldn't support its own weight. I found the same when I studied the restrictions placed on the gay community, on body modification, and on sexual rights within marriage. These things fell from my fingers without a fight.
One by one the pieces slipped away. And a broken puzzle is good for no one.
There were many things that did not leave me easily. Despite the fact that everyone has a different experience and it doesn't seem to guarantee marital success, I still purported my virginity-until-marriage like it made me a special snowflake. Ironically enough the anxiety issues that have me in therapy give me incredible control over every fact of my life and, as a result, made it easier to follow the rigid rules I based my worth on. Holding myself to such a standard meant that I held other people to it as well, and judgement became part of my social repertoire. I have said many cruel things I am ashamed of. Letting go of the inherent right I felt to police other people has, sadly, not been something that has been easy to peel off.
Accepting judgement was also something that left me with a fight. Before, I told myself to simmer down and accept undue criticism (the difference between helpful personality changes you need to make and someone giving you an arbitrary opinion is colossal) because it was all a teaching moment, and honestly, people tend to like you more when you're a doormat. Someone who isn't afraid to stand up for themselves has been a boon to many religions and so they attempt to write people off with terms like "troublemaker", "ungrateful", and "dramatic." Every time I go to assert myself there's always the voice in the back of my head that says it will be easier if I accept everything quietly, that I need to be meek and quiet and a people-pleaser.
Being entrenched in something, even with good intentions, means that mark it has made on you is woven into your DNA, like a tree that grows around a foreign object to salute the sky. Extraction is tricky, painful, and sometimes devastating. At times confronting the untruths religion had given me felt a lot like deforestation.
I am never a fan of destroying what nature has created but sometimes the only way to breed fertile soil is to burn the dead ends to the ground.
It does feel like I've walked through a few fires and flames in my lifetime and with each tragedy some religion is shed. Reality is a friction, intended to exfoliate down to bare bones until we have nothing but the truth to face. I felt that scraping. It was uncomfortable, but I made the choice to stop attending church even though we had found one full of great people -- I felt disingenuous, my apathy offensive to those around me who truly believed.
So I walked away. But something followed me.
I felt hollow in my chest, an empty place that neither friction nor fire had filled. While the rest of my body enjoyed the new lightness it had been afforded the space behind my heart seemed to weigh me down. It did not make sense; I had stopped worrying about false rules of modesty and wore what I wanted, my language flowed freely in whatever manner I chose, and the world had opened under my toes as I tiptoed around, trying to explore the boundaries I had broken. I should have been levitating. I should not have been reminded of my gravity.
But you see, I often say that people are either made to be wolves that prowl alone or meant to huddle in packs. In my desire for an all-or-nothing commitment I forgot that labels only apply when you desire them. Boundaries only exist as fences you build in your mind.
I started the awkward trip backwards in my memory to retrace the steps I took through my religion. It occurred to me that, though I could recall the moments I was embarrassed because of the legality, and even when I tasted the pain of crusading against those who were different, it was by the letter of the law. It was the law I had the forsaken, the law that had crushed so many under it's heel, the law that facilitated death. It was the law that was held over people's heads, the law that was thrown at some instead of the life preserver they desperately needed, the law that was supposed to feed the starved.
I was done with the law. But it does not mean I was done with humming a hymn when walking down the road, done with fevered prayers during my panic attacks, or done with the peace that satiated my blood as I examined creation. Boundaries only exist as fences you build in your mind.
For while the law had failed me love had not. It's true, forsaking the rules of organized religion means that I don't have the answers I would like --- but come to think of it, I'm arrogant for assuming that I possess intelligence advanced enough to have an answer for everything. I don't have an answer for the joy that fills me when my niece giggles. I don't have an explanation for the electricity that seems to jump from the piano to my hands when I play. I cannot pretend to understand why my husband has such a power in his kiss that lands on the back of my neck.
The definition I was given of god may have disappointed me but God in the essence of love has not failed me. He was not silent when I battled an eating disorder. He was not cruel when my heart was broken. He was not dismissive when irrational fears crept in. He was not missing as jobs were lost and money was tight. He was not absent the first time I had a panic attack. He was not absent in the dark, in the cold, in the pain.
He was present in every prayer and faithful in every promise because the love that lived inside of me gave me peace.
So I will have a forest for a church and kisses for a prayer book. My confessional is a glass of wine and my forgiveness is a tear shed slowly. My doctrine is my life story and my prayer is an honest conversation.
Because I have let go of religion but I cannot let go of God.
It does feel like I've walked through a few fires and flames in my lifetime and with each tragedy some religion is shed. Reality is a friction, intended to exfoliate down to bare bones until we have nothing but the truth to face. I felt that scraping. It was uncomfortable, but I made the choice to stop attending church even though we had found one full of great people -- I felt disingenuous, my apathy offensive to those around me who truly believed.
So I walked away. But something followed me.
I felt hollow in my chest, an empty place that neither friction nor fire had filled. While the rest of my body enjoyed the new lightness it had been afforded the space behind my heart seemed to weigh me down. It did not make sense; I had stopped worrying about false rules of modesty and wore what I wanted, my language flowed freely in whatever manner I chose, and the world had opened under my toes as I tiptoed around, trying to explore the boundaries I had broken. I should have been levitating. I should not have been reminded of my gravity.
But you see, I often say that people are either made to be wolves that prowl alone or meant to huddle in packs. In my desire for an all-or-nothing commitment I forgot that labels only apply when you desire them. Boundaries only exist as fences you build in your mind.
I started the awkward trip backwards in my memory to retrace the steps I took through my religion. It occurred to me that, though I could recall the moments I was embarrassed because of the legality, and even when I tasted the pain of crusading against those who were different, it was by the letter of the law. It was the law I had the forsaken, the law that had crushed so many under it's heel, the law that facilitated death. It was the law that was held over people's heads, the law that was thrown at some instead of the life preserver they desperately needed, the law that was supposed to feed the starved.
I was done with the law. But it does not mean I was done with humming a hymn when walking down the road, done with fevered prayers during my panic attacks, or done with the peace that satiated my blood as I examined creation. Boundaries only exist as fences you build in your mind.
For while the law had failed me love had not. It's true, forsaking the rules of organized religion means that I don't have the answers I would like --- but come to think of it, I'm arrogant for assuming that I possess intelligence advanced enough to have an answer for everything. I don't have an answer for the joy that fills me when my niece giggles. I don't have an explanation for the electricity that seems to jump from the piano to my hands when I play. I cannot pretend to understand why my husband has such a power in his kiss that lands on the back of my neck.
The definition I was given of god may have disappointed me but God in the essence of love has not failed me. He was not silent when I battled an eating disorder. He was not cruel when my heart was broken. He was not dismissive when irrational fears crept in. He was not missing as jobs were lost and money was tight. He was not absent the first time I had a panic attack. He was not absent in the dark, in the cold, in the pain.
He was present in every prayer and faithful in every promise because the love that lived inside of me gave me peace.
So I will have a forest for a church and kisses for a prayer book. My confessional is a glass of wine and my forgiveness is a tear shed slowly. My doctrine is my life story and my prayer is an honest conversation.
Because I have let go of religion but I cannot let go of God.
